Alan’s Sardine Stuffed Mushrooms
Ok… I just had to add this recipe for Alan’s sardine stuffed mushrooms, as I sit here at half eight on a Friday evening. He is making dinner tonight while I finish some work, and he had some mushrooms left over… and some tinned sardines. I think I’ve found my new favourite flavour. Here’s how he did it.

Ingredients
- Mushrooms – cleaned and with the stalks removed. Just your normal bog standard ‘shrooms… although this would also work with the larger Portobello mushrooms too.
- Sardines. Alan used tinned (in brine) but fresh would be lovely too – as long as you have already cooked them and removed any bones
- Couple of knobs of butter, and/or a couple of glugs of olive oil
- Salt and freshly cracked black pepper
There are no quantities there… but a rule of thumb would be around a heaped teaspoon of sardine for each medium sized mushroom
Method
- Mash the sardines with a fork. Alan didn’t flavour his, but you could add a bit of garlic or chili, or paprika
- Stuff the mushrooms with the mashed sardine and press down well. Keep filling and pressing down until the top is levelled off and pretty flat
- Sprinkle with salt and pepper on both sides
- Pop a couple of knobs of butter into a frying pan and place on a medium heat. Add a small glug of olive oil to stop the butter burning. Or just use olive oil on its own
- Once the butter has melted, pop the mushrooms in. Don’t crowd the pan or they’ll end up sauteéd instead of fried.
- Cook for a couple of minutes until the underside is starting to brown, then flip them gently. If you’ve rammed that sardine in right, it shouldn’t come out
- Cook for another couple of minutes, turning if necessary until the mushrooms are golden brown and the mushroom has softened.
- Serve hot!
I’d say that 4 mushrooms per person would be a substantial starter, or you could serve them as a side dish.
Healthy option. Ok ok… you could just drizzle the raw stuffed mushrooms with a teeny bit of olive oil and grill them – but where’s the fun in that?

Elle, along with Alan, is the owner of Spain Buddy and the busy web design business – Spain Web Design by Gandy-Draper.
Born a “Norverner”, she then spent most of her life “Dann Saff” before moving to Spain in 2006. Elle’s loves are Alan, the internet, dogs, good food, and dry white wine – although not necessarily in that order.
Disclaimer
Some of the links on this website may contain an affiliate link. It costs you no more to use one of these links, but we may receive a small payment for you doing so.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.
Information correct at time of publication.


Phil Ballard
December 11, 2013 @ 11:48 am
Sounds good to me. I wonder how it would work with ‘picante’ canned sardines? To the shops …..
Elle Draper
December 11, 2013 @ 12:32 pm
I imagine that the picante sardines would work really well. Possibly mackerel too. Enjoy! x
Carol Byrne
December 11, 2013 @ 12:36 pm
Lovely! I use garlic butter, grated cheddar and breadcrumbs, and put them in a hot oven for 10 mins – but will try this one too :)
Elle Draper
December 11, 2013 @ 12:38 pm
Yes – I do that one too! Also nice if you pop a layer of pate between the butter and cheese. Yummy!